4. R P I (1) Where R is risk degree, P is the probability of risk 0000004509 00000 n 0000003289 00000 n How to Assess Risk for New Product Marketing Plan Risk. Below is a simple 3 step process for project risk management which includes identifying risks, documenting them and then monitoring them. For these reasons, management should not limit the risk assessment … Project Risk Assessment: Worked Example pmis-consulting.com H M L Probability 20% 40% Impact H M L 1 9 4 3 level schema: (Low = 1, Med = 2, High = 3) also 5 level schema. However, that is not all there is to it. 0000017103 00000 n INDEX: ID Contents Page No . To use the free templates provided below, simply download your chosen file, and make any required edits. 0000324437 00000 n When you say product development, you are likely to immediately think about new product development. Template No Effective Date Review Date Drafted by Approved by Released by Page No 1of 4 . The example risk assessment below is a proven and reliable framework for summarising an individual project risk. Here are the things to include in your risk assessment matrix or template: Project management. Use this risk assessment matrix to conduct a qualitative risk analysis of risk probability, and gauge how severe the impact of each risk would be on project scope, schedule, budget, and completion. Vendor risk assessment questionnaires include a series of questions typically used in identifying a vendor’s level of risk … AML360 provides a risk assessment that follows each of the above mentioned processes. 0000000016 00000 n In all cases, the risk … DEFINITIONS. 0000006409 00000 n On small projects, in fact, risk analysis can often be spread throughout many similar projects which incur the same risks, thereby reducing the cost of risk management activities per project. Example of a Risk Management Plan. When to use the supplier risk assessment template: There are three ways to use this template in the procurement process. AML Risk Assessment Template and Sample Rating Matrix | Downloadable Template & Raw Data When on-boarding new customers, and throughout the relationship with each customer, financial institutions are required by regulators to perform anti-money laundering (AML) and know-your-customer (KYC) risk assessments … Download. Assessing … 631 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<0F77DAA0D293F044B105B889B077BCEC>]/Index[616 36]/Info 615 0 R/Length 80/Prev 88073/Root 617 0 R/Size 652/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream Product risk assessment is an important aspect of product development, especially when introducing a new product in the market. A risk assessment can help you identify events that could adversely impact your … RISK IDENTIFICATION, ASSESSMENT & MITIGATION TEMPLATE . Tips for Creating Vendor Risk-Assessment Questionnaires. 0000001861 00000 n These templates are also use to judge whether the particular person is competent to your organization. Urban and J.R. Hauser, “Design and Marketing of New Products,” 2nd ed. Risk degree denoting the impacts of risk factors is shown in (1). While a risk assessment … Product - material or service related risks like patent restrictions. 0000002856 00000 n 651 0 obj <>stream This can occur due to shifts in customer needs and preferences. 0000005289 00000 n 0000016031 00000 n For any developing product or launching any new product, this assessment is essential and through this assessment, the management can form the strategies and adopt various techniques to cope up with such risks. Risk Assessment Matrix Background - A Bankers' Threads user asked if anyone would be willing to share a sample matrix in regards to security/risk for privacy. H��V�O�F�_1��(^���ݭ�(ᮥ "Bp}j��1��ld�@������p�ҪUUU��ٙ�|�o^����nN�� ��uK�����Op�������K�-�Œ�ܡ����j���ۣ��k����zZp��ˍu��f������WdWF���B$�Dz��%�x���������o2��,�/��=GY8��������6w�T��&�|��1d� U. When a customer buys a product, it could be because he/she needs it in order to continue with day-to-day activities or to help with a problem that they face daily. Management and the board are wise to assess the … Project Risk Management is a basic task for any project manager no matter how big or small the project. Demand Risk The risk that demand for your products or services will fall or fail to materialize. 0000011567 00000 n 0000014479 00000 n You'll notice that the risk assessment doesn't simply involve stating the risk and moving on. Most companies are much better at introducing new technology than retiring it. Risk Management Planning Templates for Excel. Project risk assessment is a continuous process and needs to change concurrently with modifications in your organization or with consumer trends. Fire Risk Assessment Example Fire Safety Risk Assessment. They emphasize that the risk assessment process is to identify potential risks in four main domains, namely technology, market, finance and operations risks. That’s why you need to identify potential risks when it comes to project management. process and facilitate the success of new products in the market. Scope creep is uncontrolled changeto a project's scope. Project Risk Management Guideline . 0000269385 00000 n endstream endobj 617 0 obj <>/Metadata 20 0 R/Pages 614 0 R/StructTreeRoot 33 0 R/Type/Catalog>> endobj 618 0 obj <>/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 614 0 R/Resources<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 0/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 619 0 obj <>stream 3. Understand Whether Your Product Is Meant to Fulfill a Need or Solve a Problem. Risk Management Team Intranet Site . %PDF-1.6 %���� %%EOF This is a simple procedure for analysis of a new product or service. Approved NPAs split by division Our NPA/NTA framework aims for proper understanding and application of policies, procedures and controls, with a focus on oversight and risk assessment. Cost risk, typically escalation of project costs due to poor cost estimating accuracy and scope creep. An example is monday.com. Money Laundering Risk Assessment. A large part of the risk for a new product depends on the marketing plan. An OHS risk assessment matrix is a part of any general risk assessment form and helps workers put a numerical value on the hazard and risk identification process. 98 0 obj <> endobj Brand Risk A product that reflects poorly on your brand.This can occur due to customer experience and quality issues. ... Make sure to choose a well made example of a risk assessment, whether for health, personal, or even a business reason, a risk assessment … mtc.gov.on.ca. NPA is required for entirely new products, businesses and markets, and also covers changes to existing business. An example risk assessment for businesses when carrying out a risk assessment for COVID-19. Product Risk Assessment … Formulation of an entirely new productthat will meet the demands of a new market niche, or satisfy newly defined wants or needs of the target market; or 2. Project personnel should also be able to quickly qualify and quantify the risks because these details are included in the risk assessment template. At the same time, forecasting the exact specifications and potential sales volumes of new products is becoming more difficult than ever. Record your findings. 138 0 obj <>stream ucl.ac.uk. Product development also involves project risk and innovation risk. 0000007732 00000 n Risk assessments are crucial in the banking industry. [13] improved upon prior studies in risk … 0 Barrier An existing control. Risks related to developing and launching a new product. This product decision really had 2 parts. Tourism Product Assessment. There is no single approach to survey risks, and there are numerous risk assessment instruments and procedures that can be utilized. Jump-start new projects and processes with our pre-built sets of templates, add-ons, and services. endstream endobj 99 0 obj <> endobj 100 0 obj <>/Encoding<>>>>> endobj 101 0 obj <>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text]/ExtGState<>>>/Type/Page>> endobj 102 0 obj <> endobj 103 0 obj <> endobj 104 0 obj <> endobj 105 0 obj <> endobj 106 0 obj <> endobj 107 0 obj <> endobj 108 0 obj <> endobj 109 0 obj <>stream Money Laundering Risk Assessment Guideline. If you have more than five employees in your office, you are required by law to … AML Risk Assessment Template and Sample Rating Matrix | Downloadable Template & Raw Data When on-boarding new customers, and throughout the relationship with each customer, financial institutions are required by regulators to perform anti-money laundering (AML) and know-your-customer (KYC) risk assessments to determine a customer’s overall money laundering risk. For example, the bank may need to update its BSA/AML risk assessment when new products, services, and customer types are introduced or the bank expands through mergers and acquisitions. Risk Sharing – In some cases, where the potential for gain outweighs the possible risks, you may choose to share risk responsibility and impact with other groups or individuals. Quality risk management is a systematic process for the assessment, control, communication and review of risks to the quality of the drug product across the product lifecycle. Risk Avoidance – Sometimes, avoiding the risk makes more sense, such as not getting involved in a project or business venture, or not taking part in an activity that is considered high-risk. The risk assessment is vital for any business unit, and this template provides all the significant data for it. Using the risk assessment template, enter the rating for the probability of the risk occurring and record the rating of the impact of the risk should it occur. If you are researching how to do a technology risk assessment, this story is probably already familiar to you. 0000320403 00000 n The primary benefit of risk management is to contain and mitigate threats to project success. However, there is no requirement to update the BSA/AML risk assessment on a continuous or specified periodic basis. businesses into new or adjacent industries, the need for a broader view of compliance risk has never been greater. 67% of CIOs indicate their technology risk management as ineffective. h�bbd``b`�${AD��T,! Remember that product assessment is always something that you’ll need to do in the event that you plan on creating a new product or even when improving an existing one. Preliminary Capacity Study: Verification. If your type of product has never been seen before, you'll have little competition at first. Product Risk Assessment. Operational Risk Management Guideline . Completely new products typically have a reasonably high failure rate at launch. xref 616 0 obj <> endobj 0000269338 00000 n This guide on risk assessments in disaster recovery planning shows how to get started, how to prepare a risk analysis, and how to identify natural and man-made hazards. Risk Assessment Form Structure. The product safety risk assessment is critical to look into all the possibilities and risk factors. nTask risk assessment matrix shows how project risks are prioritized for at different levels. 0000324165 00000 n We originally sought this out to document analysis of new loan products but it is generic enough to use for other things. required time, and the quality of new products in a new product development project. Brand Risk A product that reflects poorly on your brand.This can occur due to customer experience and quality issues. 1. 0000001116 00000 n The example below describes the risk of new contractors being untrained and unsafe to work. Project managers usually prepare themselves by putting in place a specific strategy for project risk management. 0000014737 00000 n Most software engineering projects are risky because of the range of serious potential problems that can arise. What this really means is that a Risk Assessment should be undertaken as part of the conformity process. The process of identifying risks is intuitive for experienced project managers. %PDF-1.6 %���� For the launch of a new product or for some development in the present product, it is essential for the business unit to assess the safety risk for the product. Details. It offers project risk assessment tools and … Although a formal risk management process cannot prevent risks from occurring, such a practice can help organizations minimize the impact of their project risks. How do you plan for a risk assessment? This paper examines the risk management process used at Nokia Siemens Networks. The risk assessment of a new product is one of the most critical activities performed by the operational risk management of a company operating in the financial sector. x�b```c``9"��23 �0+P����A� Üx�%�E����JN/�iÀ��f,_ˣ?g��3����,��/{��������ݫ6� Ef��&�̽}��f����.�\Z_:=�O$P��+��>�^[�'ol2�b{��H�̤�����CHII� �k :; lFA��RZD���YD[FG�ˁ@���� ���`e!�2 �1�}�� G�B8_��P����~Ah�2F���O�3Zp����E�r>�d3D`� tH���~�7o'0�0���� ͠y@$��\ä�o0(1h0�tq%1h�p`�:���� �R�F2p��c ��|N�f����{ b93pڴifV����Up�2�܄�&2p&��� � ���= Risk assessment templates consist of an ideal sort of Performa along with the different contents, such as control measures, activities, persons in jeopardy, risk technical assessment template measures, … 0000012765 00000 n Design Risk Analysis: Product Breakdown Structure (High -level BOM) Failure Mode & Effects Analysis FMEA) Product … Validation (Design, Process, Product) Design Records. A good risk assessment looks at any new effort from a variety of angles and tries to quantify the unmitigated risk. This risk matrix template allows you to rate risks both before and after a response, along with events that could trigger the risk, the person or entity in charge of responding, and the response plan. 1.0 Responsibilities 2.0 Objective 3.0 Scope 4.0 Risk Identification 5.0 Risk Assessment and Investigations 6.0 Risk … We've also included a free, downloadable IT risk assessment template you can use in your planning. Nevertheless, according to a survey conducted jointly by Deloitte and Compliance Week,1 40 percent of companies do not perform an annual compliance risk assessment. The Simple Risk Assessment Template – Hedging Example . Go to this link to get a copy of a money laundering risk assessment guideline. Download . As part of the new Low Voltage Directive (2014/35/EU), manufacturers are required to include an ‘adequate analysis and assessment of the risk(s)’ for their equipment within the technical files. In this age of enterprise risk management, a new product or process risk assessment is mandatory. Graduation Committee members: Dr. M. de Visser Dr. M. L. Ehrenhard Keywords: Risk management, new product development, SMEs, risk manual, innovation, product … 0000010342 00000 n 0000258412 00000 n TeamGantt’s risk assessment matrix template gives you a quick and simple way to visualize and measure risk so you can take proactive steps to minimize its impact on your project. The following types of risks (risk categories) should be enough to stimulate your creativity. 0 But in order for this strategy to be effective, you need to understand the nature of the common project risks and reflect on what would be the appropriate approach to deal with them effectively. File Format. This document provides a template and example of a risk register to help businesses assess the risks associated with COVID-19. Pick the strategy that best matches your circumstance. Keywords: New Product Developm ent, Risk Management, Ho use of Risk (HOR), Effec tiveness to Difficulty Ratio (ETD) * Corresponding Author, E-mai l: chompoonoot.kasemset@cmu.ac.th Further to this, when new products and services are added, the risks should be evaluated prior to implementation to ensure they align with your FI’s policies and procedures. For more information about assessing and managing WHS risks from COVID-19, go to the COVID-19 Risk assessment … Friar, “Factors for Success in R&D Projects and New Product Innovation,” IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management 44, no. 0000324729 00000 n monday.com is an online project management software that empowers managers to drive projects and teams effectively. 0000269152 00000 n Events that may trigger risk assessment include the initial establishment of an ERM program, a periodic refresh, the start of a new project, a merger, acquisition, or divestiture, or a major restructuring. 0000320679 00000 n In doing so, it lists the disadvantages and the advantages of using a formal and iterative risk management process. Mu et al. Then calculate the PI index. Details. For example, a plumbing firm could have a risk register for a commercial building project, a residential building, a hot water tank repair project, etc. <]>> This will help ensure that your institutional risk assessment is aligned with your FI’s intended risk profile. A model for h�b```�\�"~�ʰ !�f��� =�:0^dH@*�a`T� �y���9���I-Y@|������$Y��o``mlP{ � V����vH3�� ����Qs%�fc`�c�2���10�)C3�0 k� 3 (1997): 276–287; G.L. Project risk management is a project management activity that involves identifying, assessing, measuring, documenting, communicating, avoiding, mitigating, transferring, accepting, controlling and managing risk. Supply Chain - long lead time or manufacturing located in a high-risk region. Alternatively, it can be a product that simply doesn't appeal to your customers such that it impacts your brand image.For example, a snowboarding brand that alienates customers with a … The availability of new technologies and open access information (high resolution satellite images, daily rainfall data) allow assessment today with an accuracy that only 10 years ago was unimaginable. @�9Dl�@�6�Xe ��� $b�Dd)�(b`bd�c`� ���;� \ + Bank Compliance Risk Assessments Up-to-Date Banking Risk Assessments Developed By Experts. diagnostic methodology for how to manage risk in new product development projects. New Product Risk Assessment. Scope Creep. They offer 50 Project Management Templates, and one of them is a Risk Management Plan Template. It may involve: 1. There are many approaches to project risk management planning, but essentially the risk management plan identifies the risks that can be defined at any stage of the project life cycle.The risk management plan evaluates identified risks and outlines mitigation actions. This is why we have created a definitive guide to technology risk assessment. 0000009108 00000 n Software Development Risk Management Plan with Examples. For example, they argue that risk assessments ignore qualitative differences among risks. Existing Market Risks… endstream endobj startxref 0000283702 00000 n SECTION 2 Performing a Risk Assessment 0000003728 00000 n Below are some examples of key risk … includes systems and procedures already in place to mitigate risks. 98 41 Product development is, simply put, the creation of new products, or products with new features or specifications that offer added or entirely new benefits to end users. The risk assessment template will protect your workers and your business from loss as this assessment is done before starting any new project. Product risk assessments can help you improve your products and meet any applicable legal requirements. 0000002350 00000 n 0000007924 00000 n Most Common Project Risks. First, I knew that I wanted to use Marty Cagan's Opportunity Assessment, which is an excellent and straightforward framework for evaluating new product opportunities.I think it is one of the best tools a Product … Comparing project risk management plan examples may save you time in the long run, especially if you are new to the process. Launching a new product is like entering unknown territory, where in spite of all the research and consumer surveys, your company’s product … Recent studies have confirmed the problems of new product commercialization,1 with newly launched products … When hazards are identified. Schedule risk, the risk that activities will take longer than expected. Need of Product Risk Assessment Sample. Modification o… This template can be used at any time when assessing risk and control measures but should be ideally conducted before commencement of new tasks. See R. Balachandra and J.H. oecd.org. In previous articles we’ve already answered […] 0000284092 00000 n In practice, this often means that the board approves and the management team follows comprehensive new product policies and procedures, documents decisions sufficiently, and ensures that all relevant functions within the organization appropriately engage with one another. For example, urgent projects … Vendor risk assessment (also known as risk review) is devised with the intention of identifying the potential risks of using a vendor’s product or service and manage them. h޴[mo\7v�+�K�6��}�0j�uc ɦ�S����u�ڒ!+�Ϳ��yH�\�e�N�t/��/���y�9��mr�*�qc���6��7)�]6�6�릦�w��2zD�RA��QJΣd(O(�M��Q��PJ(E�QbF�:BJ-q����g��Ji��������>z���۳7������ͽ��� �����W��Q����G�/g�FK|z������5��+��{���M�����y�~�ݿ����l���'�翿;�>xy}~y��_�==s}��׿��>�z�ڷd����'//���8��㐛�}z��z�夤Mj�zls>1쐹��w�g�W���������z��~���S~w~��T��IJ�O�>V���>��t��݂�N������OH=��zuv��. Articles we ’ ve already answered [ … ] Using the risk assessment instruments and procedures already place... Of serious potential problems that can arise customer experience and quality issues primary benefit of risk management Plan template technology... Upon prior studies in risk … the Simple risk assessment for COVID-19 [ … Using! Products and meet any applicable legal requirements possibilities and risk factors examined, collected, make... For your products and meet any applicable legal requirements for when you say product.. Steps above to guarantee that you ’ ll be able to quickly qualify and quantify risks... Mentioned processes assessment, this story is probably already familiar to you ve already answered [ … Using. Save you time in the risk that activities will take longer than expected reliable framework for an. This really means is that a risk assessment for COVID-19 demand for your or. Of identifying risks, documenting them and then monitoring them potential problems can... Plan examples may save you time in the risk of new loan products but it is generic enough to the. Angles and tries to quantify the unmitigated risk process used at any new effort from a variety of angles tries! May be many reasons a risk assessment matrix or template: project management,! Risks because these details are included in the risk for new product Marketing Plan safety assessment... Model for when you say product development also involves project risk and control measures but should undertaken. The process reasons a risk management process in doing so, it lists the disadvantages and the advantages Using! That follows each of the range of serious potential problems that can arise under this definition for new product on! A technology risk management which includes identifying risks, and categorized under this definition and the advantages Using! Or template: project management your type of product has never been greater management Plan examples may save time... Unmitigated risk is probably already familiar to you the process of identifying new product risk assessment example is intuitive for experienced managers! T manage it correctly fall or fail to materialize them and then monitoring them, including: before new or... Should also be able to quickly qualify and quantify the risks because details! You are researching how to do a technology risk assessment … Money Laundering assessment. An Effective assessment to the process identify events that could adversely impact your … See R. Balachandra and J.H long. Themselves by putting in place to mitigate risks reasonably high failure rate at launch or with consumer trends teams.. Would be extremely difficult for a broader view of compliance risk has never been seen before, you have! To project management software that empowers managers to drive projects and teams effectively and the advantages of Using a and. Mitigate threats to project management this story is probably already familiar to you can arise reliable framework summarising. By putting in place to mitigate risks a formal and iterative risk management which includes identifying risks, this. Your planning assessment template will protect your workers and your business from loss as this assessment needed... Introducing new technology than retiring it score, allowing a comparative analysis of new loan products but it is enough... Scope creep is uncontrolled changeto a project to push through if you are researching how to do a technology assessment! Assessment matrix or template: project management is needed, including: before processes. Are based on the … Tips for Creating Vendor Risk-Assessment Questionnaires urban and J.R. Hauser, “ Design Marketing. Of enterprise risk management Plan examples may save you time in the risk of new tasks risk... While a risk assessment matrix template that can be used at Nokia Siemens.! Are based on the Marketing Plan risk or thresholds ) can provide each risk a score, allowing a analysis... Fulfill a need or Solve a Problem it comes to project management unsafe to work ( 1 ) template... … the Simple risk assessment to get a copy of a risk that. And quality issues to stimulate your creativity notice that the risk for a new product depends on the Marketing risk... Also included a free, downloadable it risk assessment below is a Simple 3 step process project... Is uncontrolled changeto a project to push through if you don ’ t manage correctly. Been greater the above mentioned processes to survey risks, documenting them and then monitoring.! View of compliance risk has never been seen before, you are assigning to him/her able... Template in the long run, especially if you are new to the process the! Risks because these details are included in the risk assessment below is a continuous process and needs to concurrently! Make any required edits procedures already in place a specific strategy for risk. Any applicable legal requirements any business unit, and this template in long... Failure rate at launch it correctly demand risk the risk assessment template: management. Sure to follow all of the conformity process 'll notice that the risk,! The free templates provided below, simply download your chosen file, and there are three to... Typically escalation of project costs due to customer experience and quality issues specified periodic basis prior studies in …! Longer than expected Hedging example a variety of angles and tries to quantify the risk. From loss as this assessment is first and foremost step for formation of different tools for business by Approved Released. Are much better at introducing new technology than retiring it brand risk score. 50 project management software that empowers managers to drive projects and teams effectively little competition first... Compliance risk has never been greater a broader view of compliance risk has been... There is to contain and mitigate threats to project management assessments can help you identify events that could impact. Shows how project risks are prioritized for at different levels to update the BSA/AML assessment! At launch the things to include in your organization Marketing of new tasks prepare. Potential problems that can be used at any time when assessing risk innovation. Drafted by Approved by Released by Page no 1of 4 examines the risk assessment looks any!, you 'll have little competition at first we have created a definitive guide to technology risk assessment such... On your brand.This can occur due to customer experience and quality issues measures but be! Any business unit, and categorized under this definition experience and quality.... Is intuitive for experienced project managers usually prepare themselves by putting in place to mitigate risks and. Also involves project risk management is a proven and reliable framework for summarising an project! Types of risks across a whole project previous articles we ’ new product risk assessment example already answered [ … ] Using the assessment! Organization or with consumer trends is intuitive for experienced project managers usually prepare themselves by putting in place to risks... Based on the … Tips for Creating Vendor Risk-Assessment Questionnaires the BSA/AML assessment! When to use the free templates provided below, simply download your chosen file, and this can. That ’ s why you need to identify potential risks when it comes to project management software that managers! Solve a Problem sought this out to document analysis of risks ( risk categories ) should undertaken... Assessment, such as the abilities of that person are suitable for kind... Engineering projects are risky because of the range of serious potential problems that can arise online management! Already familiar to you examples may save you time in the procurement process,! Really had 2 parts continuous process and needs to change concurrently with modifications in risk! A model for when you say product development how big or small the project identify potential risks when comes! Example below describes the risk assessment for businesses when carrying out a risk assessment template. Approach to survey risks, documenting them and then monitoring them there may be many reasons a risk for... Competition at first “ Design and Marketing of new loan products but it is generic enough to stimulate creativity! And there are three ways to use for other things, typically escalation of project costs due to in! Be utilized them and then monitoring them 1 ) created new product risk assessment example definitive guide to technology risk,. Production risks guarantee that you ’ ll be able to conduct an Effective assessment introducing new technology retiring... Assessments can help you identify events that could adversely impact your … R.. Required edits 2 Performing a risk assessment looks at any time when risk! Upon prior studies in risk … the Simple risk assessment is vital for any project manager matter! The primary benefit of risk factors examined, collected, and this can., ” 2nd ed a Simple 3 step process for project risk management is to it enough... To materialize to technology risk assessment Record your findings to customer experience and quality.... Will take longer than expected doing so, it lists the disadvantages and the advantages of Using a formal iterative! Specified periodic basis cost risk, the risk assessment for businesses when carrying out risk. And one of them is a risk assessment template – Hedging example are risky because of the above... Are likely to immediately think about new product Marketing Plan 2 Performing a risk assessment is needed,:. Good risk assessment is critical to look into all the possibilities and risk factors examined, collected and... Activities are introduced of product has never been seen before, you are assigning to him/her a new product on... Guide to technology risk management, a new product depends on the … Tips for Creating Vendor Risk-Assessment Questionnaires will... Used at any new effort from a variety of angles and tries to quantify the risks these! To document analysis of new tasks is mandatory whole project Risk-Assessment Questionnaires ’ t it... Small the project risk a score, allowing a comparative analysis of new loan products but is.