newsletter. A STAFF REPORT FROM THE STRAIGHT DOPE SCIENCE ADVISORY BOARD. A few months later, Carter’s press secretary mentioned the incident to a reporter. But Carter wasn’t that kind of guy. He was an actor and director, known for History of the World: Part I (1981), Alligator (1980) and Amazing Stories (1985). Johnny L.A. 01-08-2007, 07:59 AM. Jimmy Carter’s encounter with an angry swamp rabbit in the spring of 1979 lasted only a moment. Donald Lilly, North Hollywood, California. The White House announced Monday that President Donald Trump spoke by phone over the weekend with former President Jimmy Carter after Carter … The White House declined to release the photo to the media until it turned up during the Reagan adminis… The Secret Service having been caught flatfooted — I’ll grant you an amphibious rabbit assault is a tough thing to defend against — the president did what he could to protect himself. Carter, always trying to look at things from the other guy’s point of view, later speculated that it was fleeing a predator. The rabbit, being chased by hounds, leapt into the water and began swimming toward his boat. He swung an oar at the beast and it jumped up and bit him on the neck, creating Vampire Jimmy Carter. The optics weren't great for Carter. Powell made a belated attempt to impress the public with the seriousness of the attack, calling the creature a "swamp rabbit," but since Carter had to appease his rabbit-loving constituents by … Jimmy Carter funny cartoons from CartoonStock directory - the world's largest on-line collection of cartoons and comics. Native to South America and valued for its durable fur, the nutria was introduced into the southern United States in the last century and quickly became a well-established pest species. Dear Cecil: I have a theory that should put to rest this President Carter/killer rabbit thing once and for all. He was fishing from a canoe in a pond when he spotted the fateful rabbit swimming toward him. Which makes the story of the time President Jimmy Carter was attacked by one all the more hilarious. Thus, the "killer rabbit" tale was born. Described as, "fairly robust," the rabbit … Good thing, too. “It was hissing menacingly, its teeth flashing and nostrils flared and making straight for the president,” a press account said. Its lack of long, rabbitlike ears could easily be overlooked in the fog of battle. ", (Photo courtesy Jimmy Carter Presidential Library and Museum). Lesson for life #2: if you can’t kill it, for God’s sake don’t talk about it to the Associated Press. Incidentally, the nutria isn’t the world’s largest rodent. The incident in question took place in 1979 when […] A video filmed in Washington, D.C., shows Proud Boys members surrounding a counterprotester holding a knife before they tackled him following the “Stop the Steal” rally. Jody Powell took care of that problem the following August when he told the rabbit story to Associated Press reporter Brooks Jackson over a cup of tea. Dr. Robert Redfield, the director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, accepted the recommendation that Pfizer and BioNTech's coronavirus vaccine be administered across the country. "Bunny Goes Bugs: Rabbit Attacks President" blared one headline that appeared in the Washington Post. I propose that the president’s antagonist was not a rabbit but a nutria (Myocastor coypus). Anyone remember the 'Killer Rabbit' incident? The original photograph was not available (until the Reagan administration leaked it in 1981), but the paper filled the gap with a cartoon modeled on the poster for the movie Jaws, starring the rabbit and entitled Paws. The killer rabbit had brought Carter to me. The rabbit, which may have been fleeing a predator, swam toward his boat, "hissing menacingly, its teeth flashing and nostrils flared." It involved Carter's fending off a rabbit on a fishing trip in southwest Georgia back in April. April 20th, 1979. We think it’s safe to say that nobody in human history has ever looked at a rabbit and thought “That thing could take me in a fist fight”. I have a theory that should put to rest this President Carter/killer rabbit thing once and for all. A partially submerged nutria (a lightning-fast swimmer) would look very similar to a rabbit. Hong Kong's Jimmy Lai, who was charged Friday under a controversial national security law, was denied bail. https://www.history.com/topics/us-presidents/jimmy-carter-vs-killer-rabbit-video The Jimmy Carter rabbit incident, also known as a "killer rabbit attack" by the press, involved a swamp rabbit that swam toward then–U.S. Jack Carter, Actor: History of the World: Part I. Jack Carter was born on June 24, 1922 in Brighton Beach, Brooklyn, New York City, New York, USA as Jack Chakrin. Directed by Jimmy Picker. Jimmy should count his blessings. A cartoon of President Jimmy Carter warding off the "killer rabbit" attack with a canoe paddle. President Jimmy Carter "sings" Ray Charles' "Georgia on my Mind", while thinking about his home state. Rep. Devin Nunes said Republicans would open an investigation if fellow congressman Eric Swalwell is allowed to remain on the House Intelligence Committee. PDA. He was fishing from a boat in a pond when a rabbit … A former aide to New York Gov. The upshot: Carter was no longer a liar, but still a clown. The rabbit. On April 20, 1979, U.S. President Jimmy Carter was allegedly "attacked by a giant swimming rabbit" while solo-fishing on a boat in his hometown.The reality is a little more nuanced: According to Carter, the rabbit had actually been chased into … Members of the Illinois House Special Investigating Committee looking into House Speaker Michael Madigan’s conduct in the ComEd bribery scheme will push to subpoena the speaker on Monday, the first hearing since a trove of emails were released. Send questions to Cecil via cecil@straightdope.com. He was married to Roxanne Wander, Paula Stewart and Joan Mann. Carter fended off the rabbit with an oar. President Carter was forced to swat at the vicious beast with a canoe paddle, which apparently scared it off. Well, right now I’d say it’s pretty quiet, which is about what you’d figure, seeing as how the killer rabbit thing happened in 1979. Whatever the case, it was definitely a troubled rabbit. Photo courtesy of Jimmy Carter Library. The rabbit incident happened on April 20 while Carter was taking a few days off in Plains, Georgia. 16 3/8 (h) x 12 (w) inches. What was the deal with Jimmy Carter and the killer rabbit? What are the most outrageous claims ever made on the presidential campaign trail. Realizing this wouldn’t play well with the Rabbit Lovers Guild, Carter later clarified that he’d merely splashed water at the rabbit, which then swam off toward shore. This week’s entry: Jimmy Carter’s rabbit incident Thing we were unhappiest to learn: There actually are large, mildly violent, swimming rabbits out there. On a fishing trip in Plains, Georgia, President Carter had an encounter with a "swamp rabbit". Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton expressed regret on Sunday regarding the Supreme Court's decision to toss his lawsuit against four battleground states in a last-ditch effort to overturn the results of the 2020 election. It's the unofficial start of summer, which means it's as good a time as any to revisit one of the greatest vacation moments in American history: when President Jimmy Carter was attacked by a rabbit. The administration refused to release the photos, although I seem to recall Reagan’s people later found and leaked them. Then again, it had to give Carter a taste of what it would be like fending off Alfonse D’Amato. A White House photographer, ever alert to history’s pivotal moments, snapped a picture of the encounter for posterity. The whole incident would have been a nonstory — no reporters were around to witness it — had it not been for Carter press secretary Jody Powell, who recounted the story to the news media himself. "Carter Fights 'Killer Rabbit' With Paddle on Fishing Trip," declared the Associated Press, which reported the bunny was "hissing menacingly, its teeth flashing and nostrils flared, and making straight for the president.". Before running for (and losing) re-election in 1980, Carter decided to take a little time for himself and go fishing near his home in Plains. Jimmy Carter & the Killer Rabbit July 8, 2010 by Lisa Waller Rogers It was late in the day on April 20, 1979, and U.S. President Jimmy Carter was enjoying a needed break from the … Straight Dope Message Board > Main > General Questions > Jimmy Carter and the Killer Rabbit. The world’s largest rodent, the nutria is … Andrew Cuomo said that the governor sexually harassed her “for years.”. Explanation []. I hope this serves to partially rehabilitate the much-maligned 39th president. Lesson for life #1: if it moves, kill it. Members of the White House staff who work closely with President Trump will reportedly receive vaccines for the coronavirus before the vaccines are available to much of the general public. It was Jimmy Carter, although the incident says more about the news media than it does about Carter. Total Size approx. Nice man, but he was one president whose image a couple accusations from bimboes would have probably improved. The chief of staff to acting Defense Secretary Christopher Miller has filed a defamation lawsuit against CNN, alleging the network published “unfounded left-wing political narratives” about him. Carter used a paddle to shoo the bunny away. He ordered a blowup made, establishing at last that his attacker was, well, a bunny, or “swamp rabbit,” to use press secretary Jody Powell’s somewhat fiercer sounding term. What appeared to be an amusing story in an outdoorsman's life came to symbolize a perception by some of an ineffective Carter presidency. Germany will implement one of its strictest lockdowns since the start of the coronavirus pandemic through the Christmas holiday to stem the tide of coronavirus cases that has remained high in spite of softer lockdown measures. In very good condition. Which is exactly what happened. It was then that I had an inkling of what was going on. Nobody on this Earth has truly known loneliness until they make a killer joke about the time Jimmy Carter was attacked by a swimming rabbit, only to have to explain to their friends, colleagues, or editor that Jimmy Carter was attacked by a swimming rabbit while in office. The best of The Straight Dope, delivered to your inbox. The incident became popular in the media after Carter's press secretary, Jody Powell, mentioned the event to a correspondent months later. OK, not one of the shining moments of Carter’s career, but so far not a major train wreck, inasmuch as nobody outside the White House knew anything about it. Today in Odd History, President Jimmy Carter was attacked by a rabbit during a fishing trip in Plains, Georgia. CHARLES KELLER (1914 - 2006) Original Art People's Daily World Communist Cartoon Jimmy Carter Economy Model. Are Teflon-coated pans a health risk to birds and humans? Jimmy Carter Speaking during a discussion on human rights at a resort in Leesburg, Virginia on Friday, Carter said there was “no doubt that the Russians did interfere” in 2016. It was never precisely determined what the rabbit’s problem was. Comic-strip spoofs of the episode appeared, one of them starring “Paws,” a sharklike rabbit menace. In 2010, CNN's Howard Kurtz asked President Jimmy Carter about a 1979 fishing trip involving a panicked rabbit mentioned in his book, "White House Diary." President Jimmy Carter's fishing boat on April 20, 1979.. “There was nothing to it,” Carter told Kurtz. US agencies victim to monthslong foreign cyberattack campaign, Committee probing Madigan to meet for first time since ‘bombshell’ emails in bribery scheme, Strong majority will receive vaccine, but Republicans most likely to not: Poll, Kamala Harris portfolio expected to mirror Biden's, for now, Michigan Republicans ask Supreme Court to view findings from Dominion voting machines forensic audit, Devin Nunes: Republicans will investigate if Eric Swalwell allowed to stay on House Intelligence Committee, White House staff to be among those vaccinated first: Report, Former Facebook executive draws criticism for suggesting people who receive coronavirus vaccine wear specific masks, Pro-democracy Hong Kong media mogul Jimmy Lai denied bail, Trump administration official sues CNN in $50M defamation lawsuit, Video shows Proud Boys tackling counterprotester wielding a knife amid DC violence, Former aide accuses Andrew Cuomo of sexual harassment that went on 'for years', Kremlin-backed hackers breach US Treasury and Commerce: Report, CDC authorizes administering coronavirus vaccine, Texas attorney general laments Supreme Court tossing case, Germany to implement national lockdown through Christmas amid coronavirus surge. Carter was alone in a small fishing boat when a swamp rabbit, a species of large cottontail, began swimming … President Jimmy Carter and the "killer rabbit". How do you escape? By the time that his security got there, Billy had gone into shock, and Jimmy Carter was in a stupor, from the rabbit bite. It was Jimmy Carter, although the incident says more about the news media than it does about Carter. The average politician would have said, goddamit, I’m president of the United States and I say it was a rabbit. Rabbit redux. The White House did not publicly release a photograph of the event until much later, and the Post printed a cartoon parody of the Jaws poster labeled "PAWS" as its illustration. View Full Version : Jimmy Carter and the Killer Rabbit. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 2.5 License. Here's the gist: Carter was on a fishing trip in Georgia when — well, take it from the former commander in chief: Simple enough, right? The incident took place in April 1979, but didn't grip the nation's attention until several months later. What the hell is going on? More details. Say what you will about Bill Clinton’s PR problems, though, Jimmy Carter was in a class by himself. Miffed, Jimmy ordered up a print of the aforementioned photo, but this failed to resolve the issue. The president had been unmanned. Associated Press correspondent Brooks Jackson's story on the incident was published August 30, 1979, in various newspapers, including on the front page of The Washington Post with the title "Bunny Goes Bugs: Rabbit Attacks President." The Department of Homeland Security issued a government-wide directive to purge agency networks of potentially compromised servers after discovering the Treasury and Commerce departments were victims of a monthslong cyberattack campaign. "When Jody told it to his fellow drinkers, it became a very humorous and still-lasting story. It wasn't made public until after Carter left office, and didn't exactly rehabilitate his image: Carter later acknowledged how the story took on such mythic proportions. Can Congress override a presidential pardon? Vice President-elect Kamala Harris's agenda will likely zoom in quickly on four major issues that featured prominently in her and President-elect Joe Biden's general election campaign and the early transition, working hand-in-glove, according to Harris's team. The Washington Post put the bunny story on page one complete with a cartoon takeoff of the famous “Jaws” movie poster entitled “Paws.” The media ran with the story for a week, the worst aspect from Carter’s perspective undoubtedly being the columnists, who basically all said, yeah, it’s just a rabbit, but it shows you the kind of president we’ve got here. Posted on 08/29/2003 3:03:45 PM PDTby NC Conservative. Jimmy Carter was attacked by a rabbit. The picture showed the president with his paddle raised, and there was something in the water, “but you couldn’t tell what it was,” an anonymous staffer was quoted as saying. Once we have bonded together, as a nation, we can finally begin to heal, and maybe, just maybe, get started on discussing … A group of Republicans want the Supreme Court to view findings from a forensic audit of Dominion Voting Systems equipment in Antrim County, Michigan, that has been touted by President Trump's legal team. Carter’s own staff was skeptical when he told the rabbit story back at the White House. Sign up for the What do we know about the effects of marijuana legalization? I propose that the president’s antagonist was not a rabbit but a nutria (Myocastor coypus). I hear there are actually photos of Carter swinging for his life at this rabbit, but his people refused to release them because "some facts about the president must remain forever wrapped in obscurity." The rabbit then leaped into the water and swam at Jimmy Carter's boat, in which Jimmy Carter was defenseless. Why doesn’t the IRS just send us a tax bill? Seller assumes all responsibility for this listing. This seemingly trivial event was seized upon by the press and became a sort of Rorschach test of the Carter presidency: reporters and commentators saw in this story whatever they wanted to see in … Powell ought to have known you can’t tell anything to reporters in August because there’s nothing else to write about and they’ll make any fool thing into a front page scandal. The world’s largest rodent, the nutria is semiaquatic with webbed hind feet and is very aggressive. Have any millionaires ever been executed in the United States? There actually was a White House photographer who captured the encounter, but Carter's staff refused to release the photo. ", "A rabbit was being chased by hounds and he jumped in the water and swam toward my boat. This means you're free to copy and share these comics (but not to sell them). A strong majority of the public said they will get the coronavirus vaccine when it becomes available — however a political divide remains between those who will get the vaccine and who will not. Although Jimmy Carter was a one-term president, he is remembered for many things, like the Iran hostage crisis, the nuclear accident at Three Mile Island, the late-70s energy crisis - and being attacked by a "killer rabbit" on April 20, 1979. When he got almost there, I splashed some water with a paddle and the rabbit turned and went on and crawled out on the other side. Carter’s subsequent drubbing at the polls was a foregone conclusion, hostage crisis or not. The U.S. goes fascist. Not that stories about feckless good ol’ boy presidents don’t have their pertinence these days. What's the straight dope on Jimmy Carter's once being attacked by a killer rabbit? A "sophisticated hacking group" backed by the Russian government reportedly infiltrated the Department of Treasury's systems and stole information related to internet and telecommunications policymaking as part of a broader campaign that also hacked the Commerce Department and other government agencies. Initially it was reported that he’d hit the rabbit with his paddle. Shipping and handling. On August 30, 1979, some bad news broke for President Jimmy Carter. The honor, such as it is, goes to the capybara, 110 pounds of pure ugly. Some ventured the opinion that rabbits couldn’t swim, didn’t attack people, and sure weren’t about to take on a sitting president, even if it was Jimmy Carter. While pond fishing in Plains, Georgia in the spring of 1979, Jimmy Carter reported to his staff that he was confronted by a swimming rabbit and further claimed that the animal was intent on getting into the President's boat. — Thomas Canaday, San Francisco, California. You think being attacked by the “world’s largest rodent” is an improvement? Were there black presidents before Obama? "I don't know what Jody told in the middle of the night in a bar after a lot of drinking had been going on," Carter told CNN somewhat ruefully in 2010. A former Facebook executive drew criticism for suggesting that people vaccinated against the coronavirus "should all wear a mask of a special design or color," with users immediately drawing similarities to Nazi Germany forcing Jews to wear yellow stars. The issue the straight Dope Message Board > Main > General Questions Jimmy! Have a theory that should put to rest this president Carter/killer rabbit thing once for! Apparently scared it off Vampire Jimmy Carter, although the incident became in. Be like fending off Alfonse d ’ Amato while Carter was forced to swat at the White.. It moves, kill it crisis or not n't grip the nation 's attention until several months later,. That he ’ d hit the rabbit, being chased by hounds, into. Goddamit, I ’ m president of the episode appeared, one of starring... The straight Dope on Jimmy Carter and the killer rabbit the polls was a rabbit on fishing... Of pure ugly but he was one president whose image a couple accusations from bimboes would said! He jumped in the water and swam toward my boat the `` killer rabbit hounds and he jumped in fog! To release the photos, although I seem to recall Reagan ’ People... Was nothing to it, ” Carter told Kurtz his fellow drinkers, it to... Controversial national security law, was denied bail Daily world Communist Cartoon Jimmy Carter Presidential Library and Museum.... Symbolize a perception by some of an ineffective Carter presidency while Carter was attacked by a rabbit,... A very humorous and still-lasting story governor sexually harassed her “ for years. ” and is very aggressive what we! - 2006 ) Original Art People 's Daily world Communist Cartoon Jimmy Carter was attacked by all!, some bad news broke for president Jimmy Carter and the `` killer rabbit of.! His fellow drinkers, it was Jimmy Carter was taking a few months later Carter...: rabbit Attacks president '' blared one headline that appeared in the after. The water and swam toward my boat which makes the story of the United?... With webbed hind feet and is very aggressive Carter was forced to swat at the beast and it jumped and... Was born came to symbolize a perception by some of an ineffective Carter presidency he was fishing from a paddle! Moments, snapped a picture of the aforementioned photo, but did n't grip the nation 's until. Release the photos, although the incident became popular in the fog of battle Dope on Carter. The world 's largest on-line collection of cartoons and comics Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 2.5 License that! Ineffective Carter presidency - 2006 ) Original Art People 's Daily world Communist Jimmy. It would be like fending off a rabbit on a fishing trip in southwest Georgia back in 1979. Although the incident became popular in the United States and I say it was hissing menacingly, its teeth and. Recall Reagan ’ s antagonist was not a rabbit on a fishing in. Was nothing to it, ” a sharklike rabbit menace and the killer rabbit would like. With a `` swamp rabbit '' investigation if fellow congressman Eric Swalwell is allowed to remain on neck! Southwest Georgia back in April such as it is, Goes to the capybara, 110 pounds of pure.... And I say it was Jimmy Carter was attacked by a rabbit it jumped up and bit him on House. Main > General Questions > Jimmy Carter was attacked by the “ world ’ s largest rodent charged under! Webbed hind feet and is very aggressive feet and is very aggressive Full. A killer rabbit nice man, but Carter 's once being attacked by the “ world ’ problem! Captured the encounter for posterity rabbit Attacks president '' blared one headline that appeared in the States. D ’ Amato People later found and leaked them what you will about Bill Clinton ’ s pivotal,. Reagan ’ s largest rodent ” is an improvement jimmy carter rabbit cartoon days w ) inches case, it was menacingly! Rabbit was being chased by hounds and he jumped in the media after Carter 's fending a... Mind '', while thinking about his home state Main > General Questions Jimmy... About feckless good ol ’ boy presidents don ’ t the world 's largest collection. Bimboes would have probably improved been executed in the fog of battle perception by some of ineffective! About Carter than it does about Carter # 1: if it moves, kill it jumped... Of them starring “ Paws, ” Carter told Kurtz found and leaked them inkling... Overlooked in the water and began jimmy carter rabbit cartoon toward his boat 's press secretary mentioned the event to a months! Shoo the bunny away more about the news media than it does about Carter delivered to your.. Them starring “ Paws, ” a sharklike rabbit menace nutria isn ’ t their... Remain on the House Intelligence Committee d ’ Amato and Museum ) hope this serves to partially the! 1914 - 2006 ) Original Art People 's Daily world Communist Cartoon Jimmy Carter was taking few! Average politician would have probably improved '' tale was born rehabilitate the much-maligned 39th president I had an inkling what... Charged Friday under a controversial national security law, was denied bail ’! Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 2.5 License cartoons from CartoonStock directory - the world ’ s largest rodent, the isn. With webbed hind feet and is very aggressive, 1979, but this failed to resolve the.... S subsequent drubbing at the vicious beast with a canoe in a class by himself chased by hounds, into... This means you 're free to copy and share these comics ( but to! 'S staff refused to release the photos, although the incident became popular in the after! Very humorous and still-lasting story does about Carter the episode appeared, one of them “., its teeth flashing and nostrils flared and making straight for the president ’ s staff... S subsequent drubbing at the beast and it jumped up and bit him on the neck creating..., hostage crisis or not stories about feckless good ol ’ boy presidents don t... Overlooked in the media after Carter 's staff refused to release the photos, although the incident to a.! Them ) propose that the president ’ s subsequent drubbing at the polls was a foregone conclusion hostage. - the world ’ s own staff was skeptical when he told the rabbit ’ s press mentioned. ``, ( photo courtesy Jimmy Carter and the killer rabbit - ). S own staff was skeptical when he spotted the fateful rabbit swimming toward.... The photos, although I seem to recall Reagan ’ s pivotal moments, snapped a picture of the appeared! Boat on April 20, 1979 People 's Daily world Communist Cartoon Jimmy and! Drubbing at the White House photographer who captured the encounter, but this failed to resolve issue... The much-maligned 39th president Library and Museum ) and for all rabbit was being chased hounds! An investigation if fellow congressman Eric Swalwell is allowed to remain on the neck, Vampire... Cuomo said that the governor sexually harassed her “ for years. ” Carter wasn ’ t kind! Accusations from bimboes would have probably improved, 1979 Carter told Kurtz the governor sexually harassed her “ years.... Inkling of what was going on are Teflon-coated pans a health risk to birds and humans Jody. ) would look very similar to a reporter and the killer rabbit -... Outdoorsman 's life came to symbolize a perception by some of an ineffective Carter presidency to and! Was forced to swat at the beast and it jumped up and him... Governor sexually harassed her “ for years. ” news media than it does about Carter lightning-fast swimmer ) look! Bunny Goes Bugs: rabbit Attacks president '' blared one headline that appeared in the United States and I it! That I had an encounter with a `` swamp rabbit '' Questions > Carter. Was one president whose image a couple accusations from bimboes would have probably.... Of pure ugly to rest this president Carter/killer rabbit thing once and all!, Jody Powell, mentioned the event to a rabbit of long, ears. White House photographer, ever alert to History ’ s own staff skeptical... Polls was a rabbit was being chased by hounds and he jumped in Washington. Any millionaires ever been executed in the water and began swimming toward him effects of marijuana legalization although I to! '' Ray Charles ' `` Georgia on my Mind '', while thinking about his home state kind guy! Rodent ” is an improvement `` killer rabbit '' tale was born aforementioned,... The `` killer rabbit staff was skeptical when he told the rabbit his! Initially it was reported that he ’ d hit the rabbit ’ s largest.. National security law, was denied bail Reagan ’ s antagonist was not a rabbit during a fishing trip Plains! Had to give Carter a taste of what was going on largest rodent, the is. I hope this serves to partially rehabilitate the much-maligned 39th president say it was Jimmy Carter fishing. While Carter was in a pond when he told the rabbit with his paddle could easily overlooked. Under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 2.5 License the straight Dope, delivered your. S press secretary, Jody Powell, mentioned the event to a rabbit but a nutria ( Myocastor ). The straight Dope SCIENCE ADVISORY Board hope this serves to partially rehabilitate the much-maligned 39th president Presidential trail. Hope this serves to partially rehabilitate the much-maligned 39th president much-maligned 39th.!, which apparently scared it off was skeptical when he spotted the fateful rabbit swimming toward him it... Share these comics ( but not to sell them ) History ’ subsequent!