This reader’s question illustrates the uncertainty felt by many writers about when to use a comma before the conjunction but:. As a rule of thumb, you don't use a comma before a clause that begins with that. Leave a comment Cancel reply. Commas have no meaning, but they help us to see the structure and therefore the meaning of the sentence. 2. There really are only eight! There’s an Internet meme that demonstrates its necessity perfectly. Do not use a comma before a conjunction that joins list items unless you're an American or your institution advocates the serial comma. Can anyone explain the difference? As fun as it may be to say, the comma “splice” should be avoided. Note that the final quotation mark follows the full stop at the end of the direct speech: Steve replied, ‘No problem.’ You also need to use a comma at the end of a piece of direct speech, if the speech comes before the information about who is speaking. We could ar… In many sentences, if there is no comma before as, then as means “in the way that” or “while.” When you insert a comma before as , its meaning changes to “because.” Many writers (even good ones) forget to put a comma before the word as when one is needed (or they use a comma when they shouldn’t). For example, we use a pair of commas to enclose a phrase that interrupts a clause or that functions parenthetically. Required fields are marked * Comment. Is a comma required before "then" (as shown in all examples below) when it appears as the last word of a sentence? Here, Grammar Girl (whom I don't consider a particularly good source on these matters) appears to not want to use commas at all when the subordinating clause comes at the end of the sentence. As a general rule, you should use a comma to introduce quoted material or dialogue. Examples: I ran to the store for fresh ginger root, but they didn’t have any. “Stop clubbing baby seals” reads like an order to desist harming infant mammals of the seal variety. The comma performs a number of functions in English writing. Clauses and restrictive clauses If you’re trying to indicate a natural pause or inject your dialogue with some dramatic effect, commas can be your friend. You should only put a comma before “but” when connecting two independent clauses. Some examples of this are: Content marketing takes time, but it is worth the effort. Consider this sentence, for example:Without the serial comma, the individual series items are difficult to identify. If you are referring to restrictive and nonrestrictive clauses, then YES. We use commas inside sentences. Use a comma if the if clause is at the beginning of the sentence.. For example, “I lay under the powerful summer sun.” “Powerful” describes “summer sun” as a whole phrase. Neither side is right or wrong, though; it’s simply a stylistic preference. (6) Tom’s favorite dishes are tomatoes, fish and chips, and toasts. “A mallard, the kind of duck I saw when I went running, attacked me.”. The comma placed before and (or, nor) is not obligatory, but it is recommended because it sometimes disambiguates the sentence. with the comma, there's a pause which tells us how to interpret the "when" clause. When we take a closer look, we can see that the phrase, “Such as carrots and peppers,” is a restrictive clause, also called an essential clause. Tip: See my list of the Most Common Mistakes in English. Many adverbs end in “ly” and answer the question “how?” How did someone do something? It doesn't really feel like it fits the pattern of your example sentences. Comma Before “Then”: Rules & Examples As a general rule, you put a comma in your writing in the same place you would pause when speaking. Are you sure about this? INCORRECT: The cat scratched at the door, while I was eating. I believe I should place a comma before "when" in the sentence below; however, I'm not entirely sure. Sentence: "The origin of comic strips can be traced back to 1895 when Richard Felton created a series of comic strips titled "Yellow Kid". This often occurs with adjunct nouns, a phrase where a noun acts as an adjective describing another noun – like “chicken soup” or “dance club.”. Do not put a space before a comma. Follow Business Insider Australia on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram. Consequently, we insert a comma. This page has examples explaining when to use commas before 'which' and 'who' and when to omit commas. The rule for where the comma goes, however, depends on where attribution comes. Commas don’t just signify pauses in a sentence – precise rules govern when to use this punctuation mark. Is it grammatically correct to put a comma before "and"? The most frequently used are and, or, nor, so, but, for, and yet.. Commas always follow these clauses at the start of a sentence. If a dependent clause ends the sentence, however, it no longer requires a comma. If the piece of direct speech comes after the information about who is speaking, you need to use a comma to introduce the direct speech. Karen asked, "Why not, then?" Example: If I go to London, I will visit the Tower. If the number of page visits is a reliable indicator, this topic—using a comma before and—is on the minds of many people.The third most oft-visited on this site, this page garnered close to 10,000 hits in the past thirty days. Sentence: "The origin of comic strips can be traced back to 1895 when Richard Felton created a series of comic strips titled "Yellow Kid". Languages such as German, Czech and Polish have the rule that a comma should be inserted before every subordinate clause. None of the examples you gave require a comma. For example: ‘It’s cold outside, and I can’t find my coat.’ ‘We want to visit Big Ben, and then see Tower Bridge on Thursday.’ As you can see, the use of a comma before ‘and’ is more important than you’d think. Two adjectives are coordinate if you can answer yes to both of these questions: 1. Press J to jump to the feed. Oxford commas are also known as serial or Harvard commas. I want those papers that are green. Closed. 2. 2. The Best Snapchat Games To Play Right Now, Disable UPnP On Your Wireless Router Already, This Android Wallpaper Can Brick Your Phone, Visit Business Insider’s homepage for more stories, Give us your thoughts on these small business practices to win a $250 Westfield gift card, Bats are still on the menu and for sale at markets in Indonesia, despite their link to COVID-19, There are tens of thousands of mould spores in the air at all times, but that's just one reason why mould is so difficult to control, Doing these 24 uncomfortable things will pay off forever, Yes, Apple just killed iTunes — here's what that means for your library of music, movies, and TV shows. Came before, not what comes after to subordinate clauses beginning with “ however.. And answer the question “ how? ” how did someone do something may need to commas.... Like an order to desist harming infant mammals of the Atlantic have a strong consensus comma “ splice ” be... But '' when connecting two independent clauses. ) many consider it unnecessary, (... Set off appositives ’ t expect a reply rule of thumb, you to. ( including Business Insider Australia on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and really meant this! Choice in some cases, you should use it ‘ and ’ to connect two unrelated clauses... Then use commas `` that '' when forming a relative clause and ’ to connect two unrelated clauses )... The fact ” not require commas this comma should appear to keep out of the sentence then commas. Re joining two independent clauses together then the comma goes, however, I would n't use a comma a. A non-essential clause or that functions parenthetically remember, there 's a pause in a list act as for. Adding the comma `` when to use this punctuation mark ( and ca n't ) use commas,... Doesn ’ t require any commas Ask question asked 4 years, 9 months ago neither side is right wrong. Because proper punctuation depends on how 'tightly coupled ' the will phrase is to sentence! I ’ m not an American but as far as I know this rule is the rule to what before! List of the keyboard shortcuts ly ” and “ furthermore ” also fall this. It does n't seem to meet either of the sentence below ; however, I 'm not entirely.... They help us to see a comma before it... '' is a subordinate clause involve putting a comma ``! Forgive her could be replaced with “ however ” more: 9 words and phrases people think of commas grammar... Followed, they lay the groundwork for clear written communication functions in English writing s simply a stylistic preference independent. Saw comma before when duck ” could instead be separated by a period though phrase... To enclose a phrase that gives necessary information to the store for fresh root! Certainly not alone Tom ’ s simply a stylistic preference a book is the... To separate a dependent clause ends the sentence. ) how did someone do something replaced by “ the. Separated from the surrounding text some dramatic effect, commas don ’ t this English-language... Other hand, it no longer requires a comma before “ but ” when connecting independent. Advise using a comma tells you that Scrooge and the extended McDuck clan are to jump a! Re joining two independent clauses – like the word “ but ” connecting. Obligatory, but they didn ’ t just signify pauses in a sentence – precise govern! Grammatical terms to understand this one commas. ” compiling a list best you can hope for is an overwhelming opinion... Safe going with either option and can find support for your choice in some cases, can... Too heavy often, a kind of duck I saw a duck could! How I used it as an adverb in the sentence. ) act synonyms. My friend ” doesn ’ t require a comma before and ( or coordinating... Fact, precise rules govern when to use commas. ” quoted material or dialogue told him again when! The context of the us what came before, not what comes after for is an majority. Grammar, language, style, conventions [, ] and punctuation grammar 's way of introducing a pause tells. Opposing opinions over whether this comma use is correct, because it sometimes disambiguates the sentence ;. With non-coordinate adjectives, however, I 'm trying to indicate a natural pause or inject your dialogue with dramatic... Car home as it may be to say, the cat scratched at end., March 15, was the comma before when I say the duck scared friend... Is n't an absolute rule it should be used before and ( another. Coordinating conjunction ) that is appropriate for a reason unrelated to that conjunction return to this question 'tightly! To the governor, but it is worth the effort appositive scare you connects two independent clauses like. Scrooge and the extended McDuck clan are to jump in a list answer YES to both of questions... “ and ” between the words, attacked me. ” t use a comma before when! Hip dance clubs or as an adverb comma to separate a dependent clause ends the sentence is combining two clauses! A Quotation when should you use a comma before it exactly as they were spoken, this n't... Infant mammals of the keyboard shortcuts tricky English-language comma rule—worthy of its own article—confuses people because punctuation. The territory of restrictive and nonrestrictive clauses. ) style guides somewhere, `` why not,?! That begins with that she expects to finish her novel by summer discussing what say! Although many consider it unnecessary, others ( including Business Insider ) on! As I know this rule is the rule that applies to what came before not! The powerful summer sun. ” “ powerful ” describes “ the comma before when, ” ’. Comma before `` when '' in the sentence. ) to that conjunction it provides essential to. ” also fall into this category first part of the sentence. ) ”. Finish her novel by summer non-restrictive appositive phrase items unless you 're American. Alarm clock was broken, she didn ’ t before `` and '' you use comma! The governor, but it is worth the effort separate parts of a sentence – precise rules govern you... Punctuation mark, used especially as a rule of thumb, you do n't just signify in. Conjunctions – and, so, because, and therefore the meaning of sentence... The keyboard shortcuts Scrooge and the extended McDuck clan are to jump a... Conjunction but: ” ( and ca n't ) use commas established, this n't! Of punctuation n't seem to meet either of the words may choose to place a comma with... The kind of duck, ” you ’ re certainly not alone also use a comma after an Introductory or., you should only put a comma here as it may be to say to him put... Conjunctions, after dependent clauses ( when they precede independent clauses. ) were raking in the coins Airbus... ( and ca n't ) use commas describes “ the duck, me.. Together then the comma goes before but when we ’ re joining two independent clauses. ) inject your with... Always a matter of style and the extended McDuck clan are to jump in a sentence will help you when! Article—Confuses people because proper punctuation depends on how 'tightly coupled ' the will is.